A new look at the Great Apostasy
This was an interesting video, and I am thinking about the Great Apostasy differently.
Even before the church was restored in 1830, there were Protestant minister predicting a restoration, surprisingly some were looking at 1830 and that time period.
Some of them just felt it was time for a restoration, but others had a bit of arithmetic in mind. They looked at where they decided the Primitive Church went too far off track, and to use the time listed in Revelations 12. Revelations ch. 12, describes a Woman (who is the Church of God) who gives birth to the Messiah, but then must flee into the wilderness for 1260 days. The JST changes the time from days to years, which is perfectly biblical.
So, they concluded 570 + 1260 = 1830
The language in Doctrine and Covenants 33:5 calls back to this vision (word links) – “This church have I established and called forth out of the wilderness”.
Protestants
The Reverend William Ward, an English clergyman, published a six-volume prophetic history between 1810 and approximately 1820. He connected the Lombard invasion of Italy and the rise of papal political authority around AD 570 with the prophetic period of 1,260 years.
Ward anticipated that 1830 would be:
A year of spiritual revival and triumph, the greatest year in the calendar of the world.
In 1809, Protestant minister Thomas Campbell published his Declaration and Address, calling Christians to recover the original Church and:
Take up things just as the Apostles left them.
This wasn’t for a particular year, but he did want to restore things. This is related to the Campbellite movement that Sidney Rigdon was part of.
In 1823, a former Methodist named Asa Wild published an account of a religious vision in a New York newspaper. He believed God was preparing a new religious movement, declaring that God was:
About to call out all his sincere children.
Wild expected extraordinary changes within seven years—approximately 1830. His specific millennial predictions did not come to pass, but his account illustrates the restorationist expectations circulating before Joseph Smith organized the Church.
In 1828, Presbyterian minister Robert Reid wrote that an anticipated work of religious renewal was approaching:
The accomplishment of this prophecy is yet future, but it is fast hastening on.
Reid himself expected major developments around 1850, rather than specifically 1830.
These men differed considerably in their expectations. Nevertheless, they demonstrate that the idea of an approaching restoration was already part of Protestant religious thinking.
What Happened to Christianity Between AD 1 and 700?
Or why is 570 AD the crucial date? That is what I am trying to tease out.
My own initial thought, was that the apostasy happened long before. And that isn’t entirely untrue. Yet, these were sincere followers of Christ doing the best they could. And Christ will claim them. But when did the breach become too great and the church really was in the wilderness and not just flirting with false doctrine? Notice, in John’s vision in Rev. 12, the woman is not killed. She goes into the wilderness. “the voice of one crying in the wilderness—in the wilderness, because you cannot see him” D&C 88:66
Let’s look at what was going on in 570 AD and the time around it.
- AD 30–100: Christianity spreads through the ministry of the apostles. Local churches develop under apostles, elders, and bishops. Persecution and internal doctrinal disagreements are already present. The New Testament warns of apostasy.
- AD 100–300: Christianity expands throughout the Roman Empire. Episcopal government and regional councils become increasingly important. Christians experience periods of persecution.
- AD 313–325: Constantine legalizes Christianity and convenes the Council of Nicaea (325), which addresses the relationship between the Father and the Son and formulates the original Nicene Creed. Imperial involvement in resolving Church doctrine becomes increasingly important.
- AD 380–451: Nicene Christianity receives imperial enforcement. The Council of Constantinople (381), Council of Ephesus (431), and Council of Chalcedon (451) further define Christian doctrine. Disputes over these decisions contribute to enduring divisions among Christian communities.
- AD 527–565: Emperor Justinian exercises extensive authority over Church administration and doctrine. The Second Council of Constantinople (553) occurs during his reign, amid considerable ecclesiastical controversy.
- AD 568–590: The Lombards invade Italy in 568, weakening Byzantine control. Pope Gregory the Great begins his pontificate in 590, during a period of increasing political responsibility for the Roman Church. The papacy becomes an independent political power.
- AD 610–700: Muhammad begins preaching Islam around 610. After his death in 632, Islamic expansion transforms the Mediterranean world. Jerusalem, Antioch, and Alexandria pass out of Byzantine political control. The ancient Christian world becomes divided among Byzantine, Islamic, and Western kingdoms.
The Church of AD 700 was institutionally and politically very different from the Church of the apostles.
But this transformation was gradual. There is no single historical event in AD 570 that clearly establishes the disappearance of apostolic authority or the change in the church. It was gradual.
Except for one event in 570. The birth of Mohammad. He is believed to have been born 570, or near that date. It is easy to cast Islam as anti-Christian – not without reason! But Mohammad himself did not reject the earlier prophets. He saw the apostacy of the Christians and wanted to reclaim them to the faith of Abraham. The Qur’an calls Christians and Jews, “People of the Book”. Qur’an 3:64–67, appeals to the common heritage of Abraham and insists upon the worship of one God.
So, what should we conclude? I don’t know. There are an anomalous number of people looking at a specific date. And that calls back to the year 570 AD. We need to understand this better. And I need to understand my Early Christian history better.
Rozy
November 20, 2026
Alexander B. Morrison’s book Turning From Truth is a good book to read that explains things plainly for non-scholars. At least, I have read it several times and learned a great deal from it.