Junior Ganymede
Servants to folly, creation, and the Lord JESUS CHRIST. We endeavor to give satisfaction

Chronology in the Book of Ether

November 18th, 2024 by G.

Chapter One records 25 generations between Ether and Jared. 22 of them are “son of” the prior generation, whereas 3 of them are “descendant of.” I would usually take this to mean they are a grandson, maybe through their mother, but Ether is listed as “a descaendant of Corianton” and in Ether 11:23 it says that he was the son of Corianton. “Corianton begat Ether.” So I have no idea what ‘descendant of’ means vs. ‘son of.’

But we do have 25 generations at least from the Tower of Babel to Ether, and I thought it would be interesting to see what that tells us about the dating of the Tower of Babel. The results are going to be wildly inexact so this is for fun only. Making it even more inexact is that fact that many of the links in the chain of descent were youngest sons begotten in their father’s old age, so how long each generation is is anyone’s guess.

Further complicating the issue is that we do not know when Ether lived. This post really is just for fun. Omni 1:20-21 implies but does not actually say outright that Coriantumr was alive sometime during the reign of the first King Mosiah (King Benjamin’s father). Assuming it was during King Mosiah’s range, I don’t know exactly when than reign was, so lets pick a date range of 200-150 BC for convenience.

So, anyhow, assuming an average generation length will give us an estimate for when the tower of babel would have occurred.

Generation Length 20 years. Tower of Babel 700-650 BC. Lol no.
Generation Length 30 years. Tower of Babel 950-900 BC.
Generation Length 50 years. Tower of Babel 1450-1400 BC.
Generation Length 100 years. Tower of Babel 2700-2650 BC.

For comparison, the traditional Bishop Ussher style chronology for the Tower of Babel puts it around 2200 BC. That would imply an average generation length of 80 years.

Let me say again that this is assumption and guess piled on top of assumption and guess. For mental toying only.

Comments (7)
Filed under: We transcend your bourgeois categories | No Tag
No Tag
November 18th, 2024 08:48:17
7 comments

the_archduke
November 18, 2024

Reminds me of my Sunday school yesterday. Can we all agree that these sorts of musings are for internet blogs and not church meetings? So much great stuff in Ether 1-5 we could have talked about. Grumble grumble complain grumble grumble.


Zen
November 18, 2024

Keep in mind also, the anomalous age lengths at that point. Towards the end of Ether we get the kind of lifespans we expect, but there is at least some indication the earlier ones were a bit long lived.


[]
November 18, 2024

The table in Ether 1 has Ether a descendant and Ethem a son, Ether 11 has it reversed, there’s a conservation of descendancy either way, though that with the Shiblon/Shiblom discrepancy may indicate two different sources?

And of course their story of the Tower of Babel must have been very different, there’s no word Babel for one (which is added as an explanation in Genesis 11). In Ether there seems to have been a warning that the people would be scattered, in Genesis it’s as if we’re hearing the Lord thinking to himself before acting, and the account in Ether says nothing about “the whole earth” or even getting to Heaven, just that there was a great tower and a people who were scattered from it.


WJT
November 18, 2024

The theory I’ve heard is that Coriantumr was cursed with an unnaturally long life.


Zen
November 18, 2024

The Book of Ether is one of my favorites. It is an epic, written by non-Israelite, beginning in deep antiquity. It is so different from everything else.


Sute
November 19, 2024

In my wild sci fi moments I imagine the Tower of Bable was another creation in a different universe and in some kind of Branson Sanderson fictional fashion a portal was opened and that’s where humanity was scattered here to different parts of the globe.

Don’t ask me to make sense of it. Just feels like the beginnings of a good story.


G.
November 19, 2024

Amen to that

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.