Fake it Histrionically Until You Make It
16-year old G. was making fun of his mother’s singing by singing in an exaggerated operatic way when his mother happened to wander in. She listened for a bit. “You’re sounding better,” she said. “I knew if you stuck with it you’d get better.” And he was better after that.
19-year old G. was at the MTC learning Spanish. He thought it would be funny to say something in class with an exaggerated Speedy Gonzales accent. “Hey,” his instructor said, “your accent is getting pretty good. That was pretty good.” He meant it.
Married G. and Mrs. G. were on the honeymoon. Say, they said, what if we sneak home to our new house and no one expects us back for a couple more days and we can play house. Which they did. She baked her first bread while he dug dandelions out of his first lawn. It was monstrous fun.
Everyone knows fake it until you make it. What is less known is that the pretense often has to seem exaggerated and over the top for it to work. You can then relax a bit into the real thing.
I don’t know how it is with women, but with men it does seem like at some point you have to embrace a caricature of masculinity before you can find the real thing. What they sometimes bitingly call ‘male-to-male transsexual,” like all those Black Rifle Coffee ads.
I get frustrated with Christians who often seem like they are trying to be Jesusy than Jesus. Maybe I should reconsider. Maybe they are going through a useful, sometimes even necessary, phase.
This is one of the goods of serving a mission for those who do. It allows you to work out the kinks being excessive.
nakedrat
April 30, 2024
The first time I heard the phrase “fake it until you make it” I had a huge reaction of revulsion, and ever since I still don’t think highly of people who espouse it. Even now I consider that phrase disgusting and the idea behind it a distortion. But I honestly don’t know why this is the case.
Yet I truly believe in the good of the ‘virtue with no name’ that was talked about here a while ago. I’m still trying to square this circle. Maybe humor/exaggeration with no pretext is the way…
Zen
April 30, 2024
Children imitate adults and it is a childish form of learning.
CS Lewis had a said, “When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up.”
Of course, we are to be as children.
bobdaduck
May 2, 2024
Lots of things in life have the form of godliness without the power thereof, but its very difficult to get the power of God if you don’t have the forms to pour it into.