What’s Good at BYU
BYU President Reece has written and had published a call for BYU to be more BYU. It is inspiring. He identifies and rejects five secular false dichotomies
https://www.deseret.com/education/2024/03/25/religious-education-at-byu-school-mission/
He is also aware of what time it is:
1. He correctly identifies the inevitable trend when religious institutions to date have tried to become more intellectually respectable and have completely lost their religious character and been subsumed into the academic mass as a result.
2. “it is worth noting that secular academics have not, by and large, escaped or abandoned orthodoxy. They have merely embraced secular orthodoxies in the place of religious ones.”
3. “the modern exaltation of authenticity often privileges untrammeled subjective experience above all else. ”
4. “To challenge the secular assumptions and ideological priors of the broader academy is not to flee from hard questions; it is rather to resist spiritual colonization at the hands of a dominant dogma. ”
You should read the whole thing, especially for the paean at the close. My hair literally stood on end.
https://www.deseret.com/education/2024/03/25/religious-education-at-byu-school-mission/
PS–there are probably various ways one could take the title of this post. We mean it as an antonym to our series on what’s the matter at BYU? That series showcases alarming indications and this showcases inspiring ones.
bruce g charlton
March 27, 2024
These are inspiring words as far as they go. But do they explicitly repudiate the trends in BYU over the past ?20 years, and intend to reverse them? I’m not sure.
I have come to mistrust inspiring words – and judge by actions. To reverse long term adverse trends entails some very tough and difficult decisions. For instance – probably a significant proportion of existing faculty would need to be removed (in some way).
And appointments of new faculty would need to make tough decisions on insisting upon faithful Mormons, even when the individuals are genuinely inferior in terms of secular standards of scholarship.
G.
March 27, 2024
I agree of course
But let us not underrate how radical much of this is, even though phrased mildly, in the context of academia
Even in the context of ordinary respectable conservative discourse or ordinary Mormon talk.
seriouslypleasedropit
March 27, 2024
Took a class from Dr. Reese. Wish him well.
Sutton Coldfield
March 27, 2024
Agree re these being good noises. Reece at least seems to understand more than other recent BYU presidents.
Getting the faculty in hand will require hard measures, at least once or twice. (You have to beat someone up on your first day in prison.) Then they’ll fall in line or loudly leave.
So the metrics to watch are 1) hires and 2) fires.