
[This started as a comment on Vader’s post below, but I decided to make it a post instead.]
Perhaps this is stating the obvious, but the number of LDS participants in scouting is going to crater. The ones who didn’t really like scouts will be gone, obviously, but even those who enjoyed it will find it hard to squeeze in around whatever program the Church rolls out to replace scouting. School activities were already encroaching on youth night; how many boys are going to do Scouts and Mutual together? A few of the multi-generation Eagle Scout families will soldier on, of course.
Now, theoretically, the Church *could* do everything scouts did, just on its own. But as much as I’d love to see “The Nauvoo Legionnaires” come to fruition, I don’t expect that.
An optimist would say that the Church is free to take what it likes from Scouting and focus on that while leaving the rest behind. In reality, it rarely works so neatly. The BSA is (or was) a living, coherent thing. It is not obvious which aspects of it could be done away with without killing it. I’m reminded of Joseph Bottum’s essay in First Things, “When the Swallows Come Back to Capistrano: Catholic Culture in America”: (more…)