Junior Ganymede
We endeavor to give satisfaction

Temple Temptations

February 03rd, 2015 by G.

There’s something going on with the story of Christ’s temptations in the Wilderness.

The story is natural for symbolic or ritual readings, since it has fantastic elements like Christ fasting for a biologically impossible but symbolically important number of days, or a mountain from which one can se the whole world, and since it starts Christ’s ministry.

But when you read the story that way, there is something odd going on in it.

I don’t just mean that it seems like an ascension ritual, though it does. Christ moves from the wilderness, which is symbolically the domain of Satan and chaos, to the top of the temple, to the top of a “mountain” that is higher than the whole world. Mountains are symbolically temples, so this mountain is something like the loftiest, most exalted temple of all. Except that this is an ascension ritual conducted, oddly enough, by Satan. Satan here almost seems to be playing the part of the scholars’ Old Testament Satan who just puts people to the test.

But look at the symbolism. Christ is first tempted to turn stones to bread.   Satan next tempts him to jump off the temple, and see if he is dashed on the stones. Stones again. Last is the temptation on the exceedingly high mountain, which is both symbolically a temple and also by nature made of a enormous mass of stone.

In the scriptures, stone or rock usually refers to Christ. He is the rock of our salvation. He is the cornerstone.  Christ is also associated with the temple, naturally, and is even symbolically called the temple at times. A temple that is made without hands, such as a mountain, is a particularly strong symbol of Christ.

We heard him say, I will destroy this temple that is made with hands, and within three days I will build another made without hands.

Thus Mark 14:58.

To compound the confusion, Christ is also symbolized as bread.

I’m convinced all this symbolism has meaning in the story. I just don’t know what it is.

Comments (5)
Filed under: Deseret Review | Tags: , , , , , ,
February 03rd, 2015 07:44:02
5 comments

Ivan Wolfe
February 3, 2015

Of course, this reading assumes the order of events in Matthew is the correct one, rather than the different order (desert, mountain, then temple) of Luke. Most of your insights are still fine, but the part about progression of heights doesn’t work as well with Luke, for example.


G.
February 3, 2015

True.


Zen
February 3, 2015

The interpretation I have heard most often for the temptations, is that they are the three characteristic temptations, that we all have. Ie. that all temptations are either an appetite, a vanity, or pride.

If the stones have meaning here, then should have something to do with those temptations. Perhaps, it is only to make him forget. Perhaps…

Forget He is already the Cornerstone and Bread of Life.
Forget He already created this Earth.
Forget He ought to be looking up to the Father, rather than down a temple tower to the populace below.


MC
February 4, 2015

Zen,

It may be intended to make him forget something he already knew, but I view this story, coming as it does at the beginning of Christ’s ministry, as the culmination of Christ’s progression from a helpless infant, to an adolescent who knows he must be about his Father’s business, to a Man who now fully understands His role as Savior.

The Grand Inquisitor’s explanation of this story in The Brothers Karamazov affected me in a manner similar to scripture itself.


G.
February 4, 2015

*an appetite, a vanity, or pride*

Vanity is a form of pride. I would say appetite, fear, or pride.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.