Junior Ganymede
We endeavor to give satisfaction

Brief History and Analysis of Mormonism.

March 22nd, 2014 by Bookslinger

Comments (8)
Filed under: Brilliantly Lit,Deseret Review | Tags: , , , , ,
March 22nd, 2014 10:02:56
8 comments

Bookslinger
March 22, 2014

Professor Doctor Charlton is a genius. A genius, I tell you.


Adam G.
March 23, 2014

Charming and enlightening.


Bruce Charlton
March 23, 2014

@Books – Commenter Thursday does not agree with you evaluation. At the Orthosphere he said about me – “He’s a fellow who has just missed out on genius, and is rather resentful about it. That’s part of the problem.”

I think “The problem” he meant was my unfortunate positivity towards Mormonism.

So – opinion is divided: genius or embittered not-quite-genius.

I must say it is a grossly flattering debate, whichever way it turns out!

But I do know a real genius – the psychiatrist David Healy – and I am a long way below him, at most a disciple. In particular, I only work about 10 percent as hard as him. (Actually 10 percent is an exaggeration.)

I tend to regard myself as at best a Patagonian Shakespeare, as in the old joke:

The Patagonians have two poets. The better one they call “The Patagonian Shakespeare”.


el oso
March 23, 2014

Now this is what I lurk (and occasionally comment) around the Mormon blogs looking for! And this is not an outline for your thesis or for a peer reviewed journal article? Or, maybe it is and I just got an advanced electronic copy. Living in the US bible belt, many of the religious leaders around here would go absolutely bananas about your mormon-loving insights. They would also get very defensive, but probably would have trouble defending themselves on many of the points you raise.
I was going to quote selected highlights, but I do not have 20 minutes to compose only the best. Once again, great work.


el oso
March 23, 2014

Bruce,
One follow-up question. You mentioned about churches being female dominated or male dominated and no long-term in between. Can you give a recent example(s) of churches that have made the transition, or that have tried and then failed? I have seen female dominated chuches on the congregation level, but do not know if the wider movement is like that or not.


Bruce Charlton
March 24, 2014

@el oso – No it isn’t a thesis – just from a blog.

In general, I don’t give examples – because the idea is that they should come from personal knowledge and experience – or not. I am trying to provide a framework to be filled by others.

I find that with examples, it usually starts a hair-splitting debate and the point is lost.

But most of my knowledge and experience is in the Anglican communion (third largest denomination worldwide) – where a lot has happened (nearly all of it bad) in the past decades.


el oso
March 29, 2014

Bruce,
I see. Yes, the Anglican/Episcopalian example is vivid and telling. The results of their transformation were swift.
I think that there are some examples from predominantly US faiths that are perhaps undergoing a slower transformation to female dominated and have not (yet) seen the outward results that the Anglican communion has.


Understanding Providence
May 16, 2014

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.